Dedicated to Landlords managing their rentals to help maximize their revenue and peace of mind.

blog image

14 Best Questions To Ask Renters To Spot Red Flags

May 25, 202316 min read

“Overall, these 14 best questions will provide valuable insight into a prospective tenant's background and character so that you can find the best possible fit for your rental home. .”

14 Best Questions To Ask Renters To Spot Red Flags

Are you a landlord or property manager looking for the best questions to ask potential tenants? Finding reliable renters is one of the most important parts of being a successful landlord. But how can you make sure that your applicants are trustworthy and responsible enough to rent from you? Asking the right questions is key! In this article, we'll look at 20 of the best questions to ask renters in order to spot any red flags before they become bigger issues down the road.

The first step should be familiarizing yourself with all areas of tenant law so you know what kind of answers would constitute an issue legally. This will help ensure that your screening process is fair and compliant with local laws. It's also important that you come prepared with specific questions related to rental history, financial stability and lifestyle preferences—all which could have an effect on their ability to pay rent on time every month.

Lastly, it's essential that you remain professional throughout the entire interviewing process. You want to create an environment where prospective tenants feel comfortable sharing information about themselves without feeling intimidated or judged. With these tips in mind, let’s take a look at some great questions you can use during your interviews that will help identify any potential red flags when selecting new renters.

Spot tenant red flags

1. How Long Have You Been Looking For A Place?

When interviewing potential renters, it's important to ask the right questions so you can spot any red flags. One of the best questions to start with is 'how long have you been looking for a place?' This question allows you to gauge how much urgency there is in their search and whether or not they've had difficulty finding a new property.

If someone has only recently started searching, that could suggest that they are reliable and eager to find somewhere suitable as soon as possible. On the other hand, if they've been searching for an extended period of time, this may indicate that there are complications related to their situation which need further investigation -- such as poor credit history or financial problems.

It's also useful to ask follow-up questions like where else they've looked and what obstacles they encountered along the way. By doing your due diligence on prospective tenants in this way, you'll be able to make sure your rental property remains secure and well managed.

2. What Is Your Current Financial Situation?

Asking potential renters about their current financial situation is an important part of the tenant screening process. Not only can it provide insight into whether a person will be able to pay rent on time, but it can also help expose any red flags that could indicate issues in the future. By getting some clarity around this topic, landlords and property managers are better equipped to make informed decisions when considering who to rent out a unit to.

To get an accurate picture of someone's finances, there are several questions you should ask. These include inquiring about income sources, total debts and liabilities (credit card debt, student loans etc.), how much money they have saved up for emergencies or other contingencies as well as if they have any investments. Asking for proof of employment and/or bank statements may also give further assurance that the individual has enough resources available to cover rental payments each month.

Overall, these types of inquiries provide vital information on a potential renter's financial health which allows one to determine if they're likely going to be reliable tenants or not. Therefore, being sure to ask relevant questions regarding finances is essential in order to spot any red flags that could lead to problems down the road.

3. Have You Had Any Previous Evictions?

It's important to gather information about a potential renter before signing a lease with them. The third question you might want to ask is whether they have had any past evictions. This can be an indicator of their financial stability and responsibility when it comes to paying rent on time.

Eviction records are public, so if the tenant has been evicted in the past, this should show up during the background check which most landlords conduct before renting out a property. Additionally, asking this question directly gives applicants the opportunity to explain what happened and provide evidence that they've learned from prior mistakes or oversights.

By looking into previous eviction records and hearing explanations from tenants themselves, you as a landlord can make an informed decision regarding who will best suit your rental property while avoiding potentially costly legal issues down the road.

4. Are You Planning On Subletting?

Asking potential renters if they are planning to sublet is a great way to spot red flags. After all, it's important for landlords to be aware of who will actually be occupying the property and what their plans are in the long term. Subletting can create complications that could lead to financial losses or other issues down the road.

It is also wise to ask renters about any previous evictions as this information may indicate whether someone has had trouble paying rent on time before. Furthermore, understanding an applicant’s rental history allows you to make an informed decision when considering them as a tenant.

In order to ensure that your investment is safe and secure, it's essential to get answers from your prospective tenants up front so you can make sure they are reliable and responsible individuals. By asking these two questions, you'll have a better chance of assessing potential risks associated with renting out your space.

5. Do You Have Any Pets?

When it comes to assessing potential renters, asking the right questions is key. One important question that can help landlords identify red flags is whether or not the tenant has had any pets.

Having a pet may increase the risk of damage to the property and this needs to be taken into account before signing a lease with someone who owns an animal. Here are five things you should consider when asking about their pets:

• Find out if they have owned animals in the past;

• Ask what type of pet they own;

• Inquire about any previous damages caused by their pet;

• Determine how often their pet will be at home;

• Verify if they're willing to sign a pet addendum.

Therefore, it's important for landlords to ask prospective tenants if they own or have ever owned a pet as part of the screening process. This way, they can determine ahead of time if there could be any issues due to having an animal on-site and make sure everyone is clear on expectations from both parties.

6. Are You Currently Working?

Asking a potential renter if they are currently working can be a great way to spot any red flags. This question helps you gain insight into the person's financial situation and whether or not they may have difficulties paying rent on time. It also lets you know how much of their income is steady, as opposed to sporadically coming in from different sources like investments or freelance work. Additionally, it gives you an idea of whether or not this person plans to stay in one place for an extended period of time.

However, there are some complications that come along with asking this question. You must make sure that you do so within your local laws so that you don't end up discriminating against someone who might be unemployed at the moment but may still be able to pay the rent on time. You should also consider other questions that could give similar answers without making assumptions about employment status such as “What kind of income will you rely on?”

In conclusion, while asking potential renters if they're currently working can provide valuable insight into their financial situation, it's important to ask the question carefully and respectfully. Consider supplementing this question with others related to income source, which would help paint a clearer picture overall.

7. How Long Do You Plan To Stay In The Rental Home?

When it comes to identifying potential red flags in prospective tenants, asking them how long they plan to stay is a must. This question can help landlords gauge whether their renters are planning on committing for the long-term or if they're just looking for something temporary. Longer rental commitments from tenants might be indicative of stability and reliability while shorter terms could signal that there may be some instability involved.

In addition, this question helps landlords determine the level of turnover they can expect in their unit. If the tenant plans on staying a short amount of time, then the landlord will need to factor in costs associated with finding new tenants more often than if the renter was committed longer-term. It's also beneficial for landlords to know when their units will become available again after each tenancy ends so they can better plan ahead.

Asking a prospective tenant about their length of occupancy allows landlords to get an idea of what kind of commitment they should expect from the person renting out their property. The answer can give clues as to whether or not this particular tenant is likely to provide reliable payments and upkeep throughout their stay at the rental. Knowing these things upfront can help ensure both parties have expectations set before signing any contracts.

8. Are You Willing To Sign A Lease Agreement?

Asking a potential renter if they are willing to sign a lease agreement is a great way to spot red flags. It's an important question that will give you insight into their commitment and respect for the rental process. Here are three key points to consider when asking this:

1) Knowing whether or not the tenant understands all of the terms of the lease;

2) If they have signed leases in the past, what was their experience like?;

3) Are they comfortable with any special clauses included in your specific leasing agreement?

By understanding how a prospective renter responds to these questions, you can get a better sense of who they truly are as tenants. For instance, if someone expresses reservations about signing the paperwork or seems unfamiliar with certain aspects of it, this could be cause for concern. On the other hand, if someone is eager and confident in their ability to understand and agree to everything outlined in the contract, then this indicates that they may be reliable renters.

Ultimately, inquiring about willingness to sign a lease agreement gives you invaluable information on whether or not the person is likely to honor all terms throughout their tenancy. As such, it should definitely be included among your list of essential screening questions during any renting endeavor!

9. Have You Been Involved In Any Criminal Activity?

Asking prospective renters about any criminal activity is an important step in the screening process. It can help landlords identify red flags and determine if a person might be suitable to rent their property. This question should not be taken lightly, as it could have serious implications for both parties involved.

Renters should understand that this information is vital to the landlord's decision-making process. They should answer honestly and without hesitation, knowing full well that failing to do so could result in them being denied tenancy or worse. At the same time, landlords must ensure they are asking all potential tenants the same questions in order to avoid any potential discrimination lawsuits down the line.

Ultimately, this question helps create transparency between both parties and gives landlords peace of mind when making leasing decisions. By understanding each tenant's background, landlords can make more informed decisions based on what works best for their rental business.

Frequently Asked Questions

10. Do You Have Any References From Previous Landlords?

Asking for references from previous landlords is a great way to spot potential red flags when it comes to renting. It allows you to have an unbiased opinion on the renter's behavior and performance as a tenant in their last place of residence. By speaking with former landlords, you can get a sense of how reliable they are when it comes to paying rent on time, following rules that were established before moving in, and any other issues that may come up during tenancy.

Getting this information upfront helps protect both parties involved in the rental agreement. For renters, having positive reviews from past landlords shows prospective ones that they're trustworthy and dependable tenants. As for landlords, getting references offers peace of mind knowing that they won't be stuck dealing with any problem tenants down the line.

It's important to ensure that all questions you ask are relevant and legal when screening potential renters. Getting references not only gives insight into their character but also provides protection against being held liable if things don't work out later on. So make sure to include this question in your next round of interviews!

11. Are You Able To Provide Proof Of Income?

Asking a potential renter about their proof of income is an important question when trying to spot red flags. This will help you determine whether they have the financial capability to pay rent on time and in full each month. It’s also good practice to ask for documentation such as bank statements or payslips that can confirm this information, rather than just taking them at their word.

If a tenant cannot provide proof of income, it may be indicative of other problems like being unemployed or underemployed. Even if they don't have any current sources of income, it's still worth asking questions to find out why and how long they've been without work. If the person has recently changed jobs, then further investigation into why may be warranted.

It's important to remember that even if someone appears perfect on paper, there could still be underlying issues which are not so obvious - so always use multiple methods (including reference checking) when screening tenants and spotting red flags during the rental application process.

12. Are You Comfortable With A Credit Check?

Asking renters if they are comfortable with a credit check is an important part of the screening process. A good credit history can be indicative of financial responsibility, and it helps landlords make sure tenants will pay their rent on time. It's also a great way to spot any potential red flags in tenant applications.

Of course, some people may feel uncomfortable about sharing this kind of personal information. That's why it's essential for landlords to explain what data they're looking at when evaluating an application. Reassuring applicants that their information won't be shared or used outside of the rental process can help put them more at ease.

At the end of the day, making sure prospective tenants understand why a credit check is necessary and how it'll help during the rental process can go a long way towards creating trust between both parties. Knowing what questions to ask before signing a lease agreement helps ensure everyone involved stays on the same page from start to finish.

13. Have You Had Any Complaints From Neighbors In The Past?

Before signing a lease with any tenant, it's essential to be aware of any potential red flags. Asking the right questions can help ensure that the rental experience is as smooth and problem-free as possible. Have they had any complaints from neighbors in the past? This is an important question that should not be overlooked.

There are several reasons why this query matters when selecting tenants for your property:

1) It helps you understand how well suited they may be for living in a shared space;

2) It gives insight into their attitude towards others;

3) It reveals how respectful and considerate they might be;

4) It indicates whether or not there have been issues with them previously.

By asking about previous neighborly disputes, landlords can gain valuable information about prospective renters before making the decision to sign a lease agreement. Knowing if there have been problems in the past will give you a better understanding of what kind of person you're dealing with and could potentially save you time, money, and hassle down the line. Taking extra care during background checks is always worth it!

14. Are You Familiar With Your Rights And Responsibilities As A Renter?

When it comes to renting a property, it’s important for both the tenant and landlord to understand their rights and responsibilities. That’s why asking ‘Are you familiar with your rights and responsibilities as a renter?’ is an essential question that can help spot any potential red flags.

Knowing what they are entitled to, or not, in terms of maintenance issues, rental payments, safety requirements etc., will help ensure the tenancy runs smoothly. If they don't know the answer then this could indicate there may be other problems down the line. Asking for clarification on these points before signing off on anything can save a lot of headaches later on.

As such, getting clarity from prospective tenants up front is key in identifying whether someone might be unsuitable - or even just unaware - when entering into a rental agreement. Having all relevant information at hand makes sure each party knows exactly where they stand legally which provides peace of mind all round.


In conclusion, it's important to ask the right questions when screening potential renters. Asking them about their references from previous landlords and proof of income can help you determine if they are reliable and responsible tenants. Furthermore, a credit check should be conducted to ensure that they pay their bills on time. It's also important to inquire if there have been any complaints from neighbors in the past or if they're familiar with their rights as a renter. By asking all these questions, you'll be able to spot red flags quickly and make an informed decision about who you want living in your property.

Overall, these 14 best questions will provide valuable insight into a prospective tenant's background and character so that you can find the best possible fit for your rental home. I hope this article has helped give clarity into what kind of information is needed before approving someone as a tenant. With proper research and vetting processes in place, renting out your property should go smoothly - leaving you with peace of mind knowing you've chosen the right person for the job!

Tenant ScreeningTenant Background Checktenant screening checklist
Back to Blog

© 2023 Keep More Rent - All Rights Reserved

(602) 806-8380